"Star
Wars and the Jewish Experience"
Sermon Delivered Parashat Behar - May 21, 2005
Rabbi Joshua Heller
Congregation B’nai Torah
rabbi@bnaitorah.org
In
the depth of the dark night, they gather to perform the sacred
ritual. A ritual performed as spring warms into summer, but
not every year. Indeed, it has only been observed six times
in recent memory. Some come wearing conventional street clothing,
while other still don the traditional garb which looks so
strange to our western eyes. This year, a friend invited me
to go.
So we braved the Jedi, the Stormtroopers, Princesses Leia,
and the occasional C3po to see the midnight show of Star Wars,
Revenge of the Sith, on the very night that it opened. This
is the sixth (but technically the third) installment of Lucas's
Star Wars saga. For some, the arrival of this movie is the
fulfillment of years of anticipation, and I can see from your
wide-eyed attention that you will appreciate my remarks. For
those of you who can’t tell a Wookie from an Ewok, I’ll
be gentle (Wookies are taller).
I’d like to share with you three important lessons that
we can learn from the Star Wars saga. We can learn something
about the nature of sacred storytelling- about how a text,
how a particular set of stories, can move people and create
a culture. We can learn something about family relationships,
and how we carry the burdens of the generations that come
before and after us. The story also says something deeply
Jewish about good and evil, and the role of human beings in
the universe.
First of all, in case you haven’t seen the movie, I
promise not to ruin the ending for you. Pretty much anyone
who was going to see the movie is already well aware that
promising, but troubled Anakin is going to become the evil
Darth Vader, that Luke and Leia, his children, would grow
up to save the galaxy. In a truly great story, the point is
not the ending, which is not a surprise, but rather how we
arrive there. Further tellings only deepen the story.
Each year, we re-read the Torah, and we, too already know
what happens (Spoiler alert: Moses dies at the end). The important
thing is the journey. But each time we read it, we gain new
insight. In Pirkei Avot 5:22, Ben Bag Bag teachers: Hafoch
bah v'hafoch bah d’kolah bah. Turn it and turn it, for
everything is in it. With each encounter with the text, we
uncover a new universe of meaning.
True fans can watch the Star Wars movies over and over again.
There are people (even people I know) who have seen the movies
20 or 100 times, and could recite Star Wars by heart. I envy
them. Seriously, I can spout a few key lines “These
aren’t the droids you are looking for” and “let
the Wookie win” being two of my favorites, but I couldn’t
take you from beginning to end. But think- how many of us
have even that facility with our own sacred texts, can recite
passages from the Torah or Talmud by heart, as opposed to
having memorized lines from a favorite movie or lyrics of
a favorite band. Consider how much time you spend going to
the movies or watching your two favorite T.V. shows. How does
that compare with the amount of time you spend in Jewish study
in a given week? What does that say about your priorities?
I’m also impressed by the Star Wars phenomenon because
it reflects a process of communal experience and anticipation.
I felt a bit sheepish showing up at the theater one-and-a-half
hours early, and pitied those poor dorks who were there at
7:00 PM. (By the way, thanks for saving me such great seats).
When I first arrived at B’nai Torah, I was shocked to
hear that people camp out in our shul parking lot on the eve
of Yom Kippur, want to be here for Kol Nidre more than 2 hours
early. They want to make sure they got good seats. It caused
all sorts of problems with logistics and security. But you
know what? God bless them- that someone cares about something
enough to show up that early.
How many of us show up at services on time, or early? We wouldn’t
think of walking into a movie 1/2 hour late. Even if you consider
the first 25 minutes of the service to be like those ever-longer
previews, we make sure that we are seated in time for the
previews. I'll grant you that we don’t offer the same
types of snacks before the service, that we do after, but
bring your own popcorn.
The Star Wars saga has some obvious Jewish links and references,
which have been discussed by fans for a long time. Take the
names of some of the characters:
Yoda- the sage creature, his name is just like the Hebrew word
“Yodea” the knowledgeable one. You can almost imagine
him as a little old Jewish grandmother, with a brilliant wit
but no grasp of syntax: “no lightbulb need I. Sit in the
the dark I will.”
Obi-wan Kenobi is referred to as Ben Kenobi. A navi is a prophet
in Hebrew, so his name means- one who is “like a prophet,”
and indeed that is his role in the original Star wars.
Or, take a line in the one of the first scenes in the original
movie. The two robots C3PO and R2D2 wander in the desert on
Tatooine. C3PO bemoans his fate: "We seem to be made to
suffer. That's our lot in life." These are Jewish robots-
they put the “oy” in “droids.”
More so than that, the movies take a Jewish perspective on the
nature of family. When we first saw episodes 4-6 – the
original Star Wars, Empire Strikes Back, and Jedi, we thought
the trilogy was a bildungsroman; It was the space opera story
of Luke becoming a hero- conquering his urges, becoming who
he was to be, becoming a true Jedi. Darth Vader was a minor
character, the villain. Now that we have seen the first story,
we realize that at the very least, it parallels the first. Many
of the things that Luke goes through- training with Kenobi,
temptations of the dark side, love for a princess, losing his
hand in combat, are echoes of things that his father went through
in episodes 1-3.
Our sages often noticed the same types of links between the
generations in our Jewish story. They say “Ma’aseh
Avot Siman L’vanim”- the deeds of the parents are
a sign for the children. Abel, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph: the younger
brother is always chosen over the elder. Eliezer, searching
for a wife for Isaac, finds Rebecca at the well, and then Jacob
and Moses find their beloveds there as well. Moses experiences
God’s presence while sheltered in a crevice, and so does
Elijah. Abraham, twice, passes off his wife as his sister, and
then Isaac, too, is discovered being intimate with a woman who
he claims his is sister. Luke and Leia indeed!
Certain patterns of behavior replay themselves in families.
This can sometimes be a good thing, as we as a Jewish family
replay our heritage. However, sometimes this can be a negative,
for we can also inherit patterns of addiction, abuse, or just
garden-variety dysfunction, and it requires extra care and force
of character to break out of negative patterns that are passed
down through the generations.
Ultimately, the Star Wars saga is meant to convey Lucas’s
understandings about the nature of the universe, good and evil
and of human beings. While Lucas is not Jewish, and some aspects
of the story are outside the pale of Jewish belief there are
many others that are instructive. Lucas presents the idea that
there is a “Force” which has both a dark side and
a light side, and holds the universe together (I suppose the
same could be said of duct tape). It is found both within people
and in the larger cosmos. Lucas’s idea of the force matches
the Kabbalistic view of the universe, that good and evil are
two sides of the same coin. There is an evil force, the “sitra
achra” – the “other side.”
In the Jewish tradition, (Talmud Berachot 61a) the sages teach
that the word which describe God’s creation of man, “Vayitzar”
is spelled with two of the letter yod, to indicate that we have
two urges, a yetzer tov, and a yetzer ra- good and bad urges
respectively. Another way to explain it is that the Yetzer Ra
is the selfish urge. The Yetzer Tov is the selfless urge. Our
tradition emphasizes the importance of conquering the evil urge.
For example, Ben Zoma teaches (Avot 4:1) that the one who is
truly strong is the one who can overcome his urges. Furthermore,
in the Kabbalistic tradition, evil is be represented by “Klipot”
or hardened shells, which surround the scattered fragments of
light.
Within that context, we see that the entire tale, which we might
have thought was the story of Luke Skywalker is really the story
of Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader, a story of his fall and his
redemption. It reflects the way in which the battle between
good and evil is played out within each of us. The suit of armor
which both protects and entraps Anakin is can be seen as a physical
representation of the “Klipah” that surrounds the
light of his soul.
Much is made in “Sith” of the difference between
the dark and light urges, and how Anakin’s selfishness
is what leads him into darkness. Without descending too deeply
into the psychobabble, I will point out that the name Anakin,
in Hebrew, sounds very similar to Ani Kan- “I am here.”
There are two ways in which we can say “I am here.”
We can say it in the way which matches the Yiddish “Ich
Bin Doh.” I am here, so now the world owes me something.
The alternative is the Hebrew word Hineni, which implies presence
and readiness to do the bidding of the Holy One (for example
Abraham expressing his willingness to sacrifice his son, Isaac,
and then recognizing God’s command to halt the sacrifice).
In the Star Wars saga, Anakin Skywalker goes from one “ani-kan”
to another. At first, he is frustrated because his talents are
not recognized, and he sinks into selfishness. But then, he
(I believe) repents, does teshuvah, and is redeemed when he
engages in a selfless act saving Luke from the Emperor.
In the Jewish tradition, the Cohen Gadol, the high priest, wears
a special breastplate with shining jewels, inscribed with the
names of the tribes. He uses the breastplate to receive guidance
from God. L’havdil (that’s Hebrew for “I’m
making a comparison that I really shouldn’t make), Darth
Vader also has a chestplate. Presumably he uses it to seek guidance
from the emperor, but more importantly, it has a message that
says something about At any rate, as it turns out, someone at
Skywalker Ranch must have gone to Hebrew school, because the
writing on his breastplate is in Hebrew (you can see a picture
at http://www.theforce.net/swtc/Pix/Xsydney/costumes/Pc220044.jpg).
It must not have been a very good Hebrew school, because it’s
hard to read, the spelling isn’t perfect and one word
is upside down. What it seems to say is “Ein Ma’asav
nimchalim ad shezakah”- “his deeds are not forgiven
until he was worthy.”
It is important to emphasize some distinctive features of the
Jewish view of repentance. Maimonides (Hilchot Teshuvah 2:1)
notes that one’s teshuvah is not complete until one is
presented with the same situation that one was in previously,
and resists the temptation. Anakin Skywalker had, many years
before, had the opportunity to save the innocent and put a stop
to the Emperor’s reign, and did not. Now, in the same
situation, as Darth Vader, he rights that cosmic wrong.
Repentance is not simply an psychological matter, of accepting
some savior or making some internal resolution. It requires
action. Moreover, it is not without its cost. One of the most
moving, and puzzling stories in the Talmud is found in Avodah
Zarah 18a. Rabbi Hananiah Ben Teradyon has been sentenced to
death, by burning at the stake, with wet wool over his heart
so he will die slowly. The Roman questionarius is impressed
by Teradyon’s faith and determination and asks “If
I increase the fire, and remove the wool so that you die, will
you take me to eternal life with you?” Rabbi Hananiah
ben Teradyon replies “Yes.” The Questionarius ends
the rabbi’s torture, and himself is engulfed in the flames,
as a heavenly voice cries out that both rabbi and Questionarius
are welcome in the world to come.
There are many puzzling aspects to the story, but one thing
is clear- that no matter what one may have done, the doorway
of repentance is open, but the cost of admission is not free.
Vader redeems himself by doing the right thing where he once
did wrong, and turns back from evil, but it is at the cost of
his life.
Most of us do not live our lives at the extremes of good and
evil. Even so, as we see the movie we recognize that our role
in the universe is not limited to ourselves- parents and children
have the ability to redeem each other through their actions.
Many times I have seen a young parent, distanced from Judaism,
who returns for the sake of childrens’ continuing connection
to our faith. Conversely, tragically, many children only find
their Jewish roots when they begin saying kaddish for a parent.
It is not just long, long ago, in a galaxy far, far away, that
parents and children may redeem each other. Let it not be at
the terrible, ultimate cost.
So,
if you go to see this movie, first of all I recommend an earlier
show. But more than that, consider these points:
When you get “into” some aspect of popular culture,
will you give as much thought and attention to your Jewish study?
For better or worse, we are products of our family. The rabbis
said ma'aseh avot siman l'banim- the children replay the events
of the fathers. That does not mean that if your mom had a haircut
that looks like two croissants tacked to the side of her head,
someday you must do the same, but it means that we must be vigilant
for the positives and negatives of our family legacy. We have
the ability to draw our parents, and our children, back to the
tradition, and they may draw us as well.
Finally, we can observe a profound lesson about the nature of
human beings and repentance- we are drawn between good and evil.
Selfishness need not win. At any point we can be redeemed, if
we are willing to do what is necessary.
Shabbat shalom, and may the force be with you.